Automated Summary
Tax Type
Unpaid taxes owed to Tanzania Revenue Authority (TRA) for the period 2006-2020
Key Facts
The African Walking Company Limited, incorporated in November 1998, was petitioned for winding up by its directors due to severe financial losses from COVID-19 pandemic effects on its tourism business. The company owed TZS. 842,405,886.88 to TRA for unpaid taxes, plus other debts to Karibu Africa Safaris Ltd and Pangani Beach Hotel Limited. During liquidation, the liquidator (Mr. Mosses Ebenezer) collected TZS. 37,440,000 from sale of assets and paid TZS. 6,000,000 to Nelson Loy and TZS. 11,500,000 to Ascend Legal Solutions as 'secured creditors'. The Court ruled these were not properly secured creditors and that TRA as preferential creditor should have priority. The court annulled the liquidator's distribution decision and ordered TRA to recover the amounts from the two parties, while approving the liquidation report and dissolving the company.
Issues
- The court examined whether Mr. Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions qualified as secured creditors under Tanzanian law. The judge found neither party held registered security interests over company property, as mere debt agreements without registered charges do not create secured creditor status. The Liquidator failed to demonstrate any valid, enforceable security over movable or immovable property of the company.
- The court addressed whether the Liquidator correctly prioritized debts in the winding up process. The judge ruled that preferential creditors, including the Tanzania Revenue Authority, must be paid before any secured creditors under Section 367(1) of the Companies Act. The court ordered recovery of amounts TZS. 6,000,000/= and TZS. 11,500,000/= improperly paid to Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions.
- The court determined that the Liquidator failed to follow statutory rules for prioritizing debts, resulting in preferential creditors being skipped. The judge exercised authority under the Companies Act to annul the improper distribution and order TRA to recover funds from Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions, affirming that the Liquidator must act in the interests of all creditors collectively.
Tax Years
- 2016
- 2009
- 2015
- 2020
- 2010
- 2018
- 2014
- 2008
- 2019
- 2017
- 2012
- 2011
- 2007
- 2006
- 2013
Holdings
The court held that the Liquidator improperly paid purported secured creditors (Mr. Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions) from pooled funds instead of from specific secured assets, and that preferential creditors (Tanzania Revenue Authority) should have priority over these debts under Section 367(1) of the Companies Act. The court annulled the Liquidator's priority decision, ordered TRA to recover TZS 6,000,000/= and TZS 11,500,000/= from the respective parties, approved the Liquidator's Final Report subject to modification, dissolved the African Walking Company Limited, and discharged the Liquidator.
Remedies
- Pursuant to section 307 of the Companies Act, the Liquidator, Mr. Moses Ebenezer, (Advocate), is hereby unconditionally released and discharged from the office of the Liquidator of the African Walking Company Limited from the date of this Order.
- The Final Report/ return of the Liquidator on winding up of the African Walking Company Limited dated 30th June 2025 and filed in this Court on the same date, is hereby approved subject to the modification made by this Ruling.
- The African Walking Company Limited, a company with certificate of Incorporation No. 35300, dated 30th day of November 1998, is hereby dissolved.
- The Court annuls the portion of the Liquidator's decision on the order of priority in distributing the realized assets. The Court orders that the preferential debts owed to Tanzania Revenue Authority should have been paid in priority over the debts of Mr. Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions. The amounts of TZS. 6,000,000/= and TZS. 11,500,000/= are declared recoverable from Mr. Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions respectively by the Tanzania Revenue Authority (TRA) as civil debts.
Tax Issue Category
Other
Legal Principles
Section 367(1) and (2) of the Companies Act, CAP 212 establishes that in winding up, preferential debts must be paid in priority to all other debts, including secured and unsecured creditors. Government taxes, local rates, customs and excise dues due within twelve months before the relevant date are preferential debts. A secured creditor must have a valid and enforceable security interest over movable property or a valid mortgage over immovable property that is registered to be recognized as secured. The Court retains control over the liquidation process under Section 301(3) of the Companies Act, and a liquidator must follow statutory rules for prioritizing debt distribution. Purported secured creditors who were paid from pooled funds rather than specific secured assets, and who did not have registered security interests, were improperly paid before the preferential creditor (TRA).
Precedent Name
King v Michael Faraday & Partners Ltd
Cited Statute
- Companies Act CAP 212
- Companies Insolvency Rules 2005
Judge Name
Gonzi, J.
Passage Text
- The Liquidator informed the Court that the first secured Creditor Mr. Nelson Loy was engaged by the Company to keep custody of the company's assets and that he had an agreement with the company that he would be paid the agreed amount at the time of disposing of the company's assets. I find that by merely having a debt agreement with the company sought to be wound up, the said Mr. Nelson Loy did not thereby become a secured creditor in absence of a registered, valid and enforceable security over any movable or immovable property of the company. The same goes for the second alleged secured creditor namely Ascend Legal Solutions. The Liquidator just showed that the company was indebted to them. The Liquidator did not show that the debt of the said Law Firm was secured by a registered, valid and enforceable security over any particular movable or immovable property of the company. I find it as a fact that, based on the report filed by the Liquidator and his verbal narrations in Court, neither Mr. Nelson Loy nor Ascend Legal Solutions was a secured creditor of the African Walking Company Limited which is now under winding up proceedings.
- In that regard, I annul that portion of the Liquidator's decision on the order of priority in distributing the realized assets of the African Walking Company Limited. I order that the preferential debts which the company owes Tanzania Revenue Authority should have been paid in priority over the debts of Mr. Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions who were improperly and illegally paid TZS. 6,000,000/= and TZS. 11,500,000/= respectively. As the said amounts have already been paid by the Liquidator and received by the said Mr. Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions, the Court does hereby declare that the amounts of TZS. 6,000,000/= and TZS. 11,500,000/= are recoverable from Mr. Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions, respectively, by the Tanzania Revenue Authority (TRA) as civil debts.
- Although normally the ordinary creditors share the available assets equally, the expenses of the insolvency and the preferential creditors must be paid before any assets become available to other creditors. The ordinary creditors are a residual class comprising all creditors not specifically designated as preferential. Under the Laws of Tanzania, preferential creditors take priority. Section 367 (1) of the Companies Act provides that: In a winding up, the company's preferential debts shall be paid in priority to all other debts. Therefore, I find that even if the said Mr. Nelson Loy and Ascend Legal Solutions were secured creditors of the African Walking Company Limited, that status would not entitle them to be paid their debts by the Liquidator in priority over the Tanzania Revenue Authority. Under section 367 (1) and (2) of the Companies Act, Tanzania Revenue Authority on behalf of the Government, is a preferential creditor protected by the law and entitled to be paid first before the debts of the secured and unsecured creditors could be paid by the liquidator in the course of winding up of a company.